January 17, 2016

Collecting Coins is NOT Rational: Part 1.

Collecting coins is not rational. Never was. And, this is not just for necromancers, either.
   We like to think of ourselves as guided by rationality. Not true. Psychological science has weighed in on this long ago: we make irrational judgments and decisions every day. Yet, we believe that we carefully consider data before making important decisions. And, sometimes we do. But most of the time, NOT!
   Coin collecting -- all collecting, really -- is (was) never rational. In this series, I will tell you why.
   Of course rational pleas surround us. CDN publishing tries to sell us "the most important numismatic investment you can make" by hawking its greysheets and bluesheets. Bowers and other (pro-market) luminaries emphasize the "good buys" that can be discovered in a few minute details (extra feather anyone?). Plus, there are commentators who envision an "all-seeing, all-knowing" rational collector (see the "Market Whimsy" column in The Numismatist).
   I do enjoy reading all of this. But all this talk is wrong-headed.
   They confuse market-minded, investment-oriented attitudes with those of the true collector. Yes, coin collecting for most folks is about supply and demand -- the smart buyer is king (or as Heritage titles their magazine, The Intelligent Collector). So sad.
   I must be kind and allow that there is nothing wrong with being a collector-investor. No one wants to feel like they are throwing their money away. And, no one wants to feel duped by a wheeler-dealer (who really is in it for the dollars). It is true that many "collectors" enjoy the marketplace and revel in telling how they nabbed a rare coin for a pittance.
   Let's be clear however, pure collecting is antithetical of investing. They do not go hand-in-hand like new lovers looking for a secluded space. It might be the case that pure collecting is an ideal never truly achieved, for who has not stumbled on, and purchased, a rare item for the sole purpose of trading it later. This is the apple that sends us out into the cold.
   Why are we shivering? Why do so many folks get mad when the U.S. Mint does not sell them ready-made rare coins for which a profit can be turned before they arrive in the post? Yes, this anger is the latest perversion of coin collectors who have lost their way! Poor souls.
   The necromancer has no sorrow for those folks whose frontal lobes have been scrubbed with promises of investment bliss. Numismatic heroism is not what it used to be. Instead, it is about "beating" the Redbook and gyrating in the end zone. Is this rational? Probably not, but it pretends to be.

Now back to my original point: If pure collecting is irrational, then what does this mean? Are pure collectors (i.e., those intrinsically motivated) as silly as the so-called rational folks looking for a deal?
   Here is the short answer. Pure collecting is irrational because it is all about the magic. And magic is not rational.
   Let's break it down. True collecting is about ascribing meaning to an object, moving it out of the realm of the useful and into the realm of the symbolic. As such, it is deeply personal. This transition from the useful to the symbolic is a creative act. It is about making (or finding) meaning in your life. There is nothing rational about that! Consider this: a chain cent means completely different things to different collectors -- ten collectors, ten different meanings! Each collector has a specific reason for wanting one of these wonderful cents.
   None of this is lost on the necromancer who tends to search for meaning in relics that were used -- heavily so -- and thereby hold the spirits of all who touched it. Any hint of acquisitiveness dampens the flame.
   Of course, we must learn to tolerate some dampening, as most relics have to be purchased nowadays. Not all of us have shovels at the ready. So money (and some assessment of value) has to be reckoned with. So be it.
   With this intro, I will list five irrational qualities of the true collector. Coming up.

January 9, 2016

Loving the Unloved: Woody Lincoln Cent Burns a Fiery Red

We often do not think about Lincoln cents when we search for evocative patterns of corrosion. Yet, the wheaties were in pockets, purses, and registers for half a century, and many were lost in the parking lot or beneath the hutch.
   Despite these large numbers, striking examples with original surfaces set afire by corrosion are hard to find. You can search dealer junk bins at a big show or browse hundreds of EBay listings on Saturday morning and not find one that grabs you.
   Where are they?
   Well, many are still in the parking lot. Folks don't pick up pennies anymore.
   Others are buried in rolls or bargain bags of wheaties. Most dealers will not waste a 2x2 holder for a "scudzy" coin. Of course, they are cheap when found -- unless you have to buy the whole roll or bag.
   One approach is to check the scarce dates -- like this 1914-S. These are set aside as fillers. Fillers? What are fillers anyway?
   I try not to buy a coin that I am already unhappy with. What's the point. I might fall out of love with a coin, but I do not add a coin that is just a place-holder. It is important to remember that necromancers do not fill penny boards -- instead, we look for magic.
   This one is not a filler. It has magic. It was lost, probably looked for, and then found (and saved from oblivion -- probably due to the "S" mint mark). The act of saving it made it special. We animate the coin.
   It was probably a woody cent when it first began to tone. I have seen this pattern before: first streaks, then blotches, and finally reds, browns, and blacks. The alloy mix was unfriendly at the start. The surfaces were charged up and unstable. But once the cent found its hiding place, moisture and soot pushed the issue.
   Now it is a piece to behold. It looks pained. And, there is complexity in the grimace. An artist could not have brushed it more expertly. This cent exhibits the awful beauty that jots us to pay attention -- of course, red tones never fail to excite.

January 1, 2016

Collecting Jamestown: Part 3. Irish Coppers Found.

I am having fun, as the new year comes in. I hope you are too.
   It has been a challenge exploring and collecting coins (plus tokens and jetons) similar to those unearthed at Jamestown. This is an endeavor that suits the necromancer -- namely, hunting for relics linked by a dug history.
   In this post, I share my latest discoveries: Two Irish pennies dated 1601 and 1602. These are thin pieces, the width of a thumbnail, meager and fragile. Yet, compared the ha'penny a few weeks ago, they are twice. Still, I find it amazing that these razors were found at all -- even more amazing is that these thin coppers survived the ravages of Mother Nature.
   And found they were. One hundred and thirty-eight Irish coins (17 of them half-pennies) have been excavated from the loamy soil within James Fort. This is more than anywhere else in the world, even Ireland (so says Beverly Straube, one of the chief archaeologists on the site). Why so many? This question has a complicated answer, and not everyone agrees that the answer has been discovered -- but what intrigue there is.
Two Irish pennies similar to those found throughout Jamestown.
Most of them were discovered in a well located in the center of the palisaded
fort where they were buried (tossed away?) during the clean-up in 1610.
These pieces represent some of the earliest coins in Virginia.
   Apparently, the Irish pieces were minted in order to pay occupying English troops in Ireland. It was an expedient coinage meant to be used in Ireland only and traded for British currency when the soldiers returned home. But these copper pieces were not popular, and most were quickly traded or went unused. Straube's conjecture is that these coins were sent to Jamestown to provide a medium of exchange with the same stipulations (as in Ireland) that would allow the coppers to be traded for British money later on.
   Consequently, the large number of Irish pieces -- all dated 1601-02, and authorized by Elizabeth I -- represents a failed experiment. One or two other pieces have been found along the James River in Virginia, but all the rest come from Jamestown.
   Quite a story!
   Most of the pieces (nearly three-quarters) were discovered in sealed contexts within the palisaded fort. Six were found among the soldiers' pits whereas larger groupings were dispersed within the cellars of a few primitive buildings dating before 1610.
   The majority, however, was found in John Smith's well, located in the center of the fort. It has been suggested that the pieces were dumped there after Lord De La Warr ordered that the fort be cleared of debris and rebuilt. Keep in mind that he arrived in June 1610 and discovered the fort to be in ruins. Most of the colonists had died of starvation the previous winter (1609-10) -- a period known as the "starving time."

In collecting them, I decided on one penny of each date. They are scarce but available with persistent hunting. I found one at the Baltimore Coin Expo; the second one came from an UK dealer via EBay. For the colonial collector, these pieces represent some of the first coins present the English colonies (even if they were not paid out or spent).
   I enjoy the ruggedness of these pennies. Battered coins such as these might be shunned by insensitive collectors -- but once you embrace the Jamestown connection, they begin to glow. They represent great relic coins that can be collected in any condition, as the ones from Jamestown ranged from scudzy to less so. I chose less so.
   I feel that the spirits of Jamestown reside within the dotted borders of these pennies even if these particular coins were not dug within the palisades. But, together with the silver ha'penny, I am getting closer to drawing them out.

December 27, 2015

Significant Coins: Making an Emotional Connection

When I attend the local coin club meetings, I notice that most folks have their Redbooks in hand. It is all about the values. And the mintages. Lists of numbers and letters. Like a code. Many conversations take the same worn path: "I got this VF coin for F money." (Insert some dollar value here.)
   Wait! That's not right. I should have quoted: "I got this MS-63 for MS-60 money." Yes, new and shiny is what it is all about. Just makes the heart flutter, doesn't it? Just knowing you got a deal on a shiny coin is electric. Sort of like getting a new snowman sweater at Walmart for 60% off!
   Sixty Percent!
   Well, I hope that those of you following this blog made some good coin deals in 2015. But I also hope that you discovered something special -- something that you will keep forever. Is a MS-63 purchased at MS-60 money a keeper?
   You notice that I did not say anything about the coin itself. Unfortunately, many folks have little else to say. Oh, maybe they will point out that Ms. Liberty's cheek is free of acne or other scars: "Nice cheeks!" Or perhaps one or two breast feathers are more defined: "Full details!"
This cent was given to me just before my mother passed.
It has a lovely patina with the added benefit of a scabrous
texture that adds depth, stimulates interest, and announces
an authority that only an old cent, once spent, lost, found,
and finally collected, can claim. No mint-state piece comes
close to the relic-ness on an old piece like this one.
   Let's take a moment and sound the trumpets for the smart buyers! HONK! Really, I am trying to be kind here. I want to shout out to those who made the good buys. It takes practice after all. One book likens it to playing a good round of golf. Bravo!

But what about the coin collecting necromancer? What spirits animate a mint-fresh Morgan Dollar that sat in a canvas bag for a century or so? I suppose the artistry is enough. For me however, I want a coin that has some connection to the past other than just being old. Oldness is good, but it is not enough. It has to have been touched, spent, lost, searched for, and so on.
   Have we lost the childlike enthusiasm that we had when we discovered an old coin in the dirt, behind the hutch, in an old drawer? Or even the curious piece found in a junk bin of old coins? I hope not.
   The necromancer cares not so much about value. The necromancer cares about storylines. Yes, coins are mute. But we enliven them. A crusty old piece pulls us to make sense of it. Such "collector coins" wear their storylines on the surface. And the necromancer gets to play a starring role by selecting the piece to be set aside, pondered, and added to the collection. This transformation -- from cull or bullion to something special -- lies at the core of the collecting process. We become attached to the coin. And we give the coin a meaningful role in our collection.
   As I noted several weeks ago, my mother set aside an old large cent when she was a girl. She found it at a dump in Providence, RI, in the 1940s. And now I have it. It is a keepsake. A family heirloom. But its value will not be found in the Redbook.
   For the coin collecting necromancer, there are many similar coins out there just waiting to be discovered. As my upcoming book will point out: it takes some diligent searching to find worn, battered, and/or corroded coins that shout out to be collected.
   So go find your "dump" coin. You do not need to wait for your mother to find it for you.